Account Links: Cart | Your Account

Skip to content

Rate this page del.icio.us  Digg slashdot StumbleUpon

WALL-E, a Bill C-61 copyright criminal. (Spolier ALERT)

by T. Colin Dodd

SFFaudio » Blog Archive » WALL-E, a Bill C-61 copyright criminal.

But the really sad part, the part none of those young kids in the theatre knew, the truly despicable part, is that poor Wall-E would be deemed a dirty copyright criminal under Canada’s new copyright law. Bill C-61 would criminalize much of Wally’s behavior in the film. Now that’s something to really cry about!

Here’s the evidence against WALL-E documented in the movie (**SPOILER WARNING**):

1. WALL-E records audio from his favorite movie, Hello Dolly, putting in onto his own digital recorder (bypassing the macrovision DRM on the tape). A COPYRIGHT CRIME UNDER C-61

2. WALL-E archives the audio, he doesn’t merely time-shift it. He listens repeatedly! A COPYRIGHT CRIME UNDER C-61

3. WALL-E shares his DRM-broken music with his friend, another robot named EVE. A COPYRIGHT CRIME UNDER C-61

4. WALL-E watches Hello Dolly on multiple evenings, on the screen of an iPod. Hello Dolly is not available through the iTunes store, therefore he broke the videocassette DRM when he platform shifted it. A COPYRIGHT CRIME UNDER C-61

3 responses to “WALL-E, a Bill C-61 copyright criminal. (Spolier ALERT)”

  1. matt says:

    The next step will be the unilateral ban on the WALL-E movie and merch due to the depiction of illegal activities.

  2. patrick says:

    Wall-E totally looks like the robot from “Short Circuit”… minus the cheesy 80’s style of course

  3. naitcorp » Blog Archive » Wall-E says:

    […] Ayer, le robe tiempo al tiempo y me fui con mis dos amores a disfrutar una película que se la puede describir como genial, que una animación de un robot pueda transmitir tanto sentimiento es algo sensacional me he quedado enamorado de esta película. Pero el post era solo para mostrar dos cosas completamente distintas. La primera, la escena que más me gusta sobre todo por el “ingenio” de wall-e vs mo; y la segunda (SPOILER), el link donde se explica por que wall-e está infringiendo el famoso DRM, que también es algo re-genial. […]

Leave a reply

Subscribe


more RSS feeds

Now playing


Quicktime | Real
Real Stream | Ogg Theora

Recent postings

Content Owners Must Consider Fair Use

OOXML Wins ISO Nod

Open Source Software Licensing Train Wreck Averted

The Liability of License Enforcement

Universities grow weary of pirate chase

Posts by category

Monthly archives

More info

Leadership
Public policy

Red Hat Press
Red Hat Magazine
Dev Fu
Red Hat People

Search our archives

Entries (RSS) and Comments (RSS). Truth Happens is powered by Lyceum and WordPress.


Copyright © 2007 Red Hat, Inc. All rights reserved.
Valid XHTML : Privacy Policy : Terms of Use : Patent promise : Company : Contact